EXPLORINEER
en

Hacker News

Quad9 (DNS Resolver) to Exit France

SecurityFirst seen 1,320 points456 comments


Quad9, a free internet security service, will stop serving users in France starting November 24. A French court ruled against it in a copyright case brought by beIN, a sports broadcaster.

What happened

A French court ruled that Quad9 must block some website names for users in France. Quad9 says it cannot follow this order and still keep its promises. So it will pull its free service out of France on Tuesday, November 24.

Key numbers and facts

  • The court cut the daily fine from €580,000 to €1,000 per day.
  • The service starts leaving France on November 24.
  • Quad9 charges nothing for its service and does not need sign-up or proof of identity.
  • Quad9 says its service protects hundreds of millions of users.

Background

Quad9 is a DNS resolver. DNS is like the internet's phone book: it turns a website name into the address a computer uses to reach it. beIN, a Qatari company with offices in France, says some websites share its sports broadcasts without permission. It asked the court to make Quad9 block those website names. Quad9 is a nonprofit based in Switzerland and says it has no link to those sites.

Why it matters

Quad9 says it cannot tell which users are in France, so it cannot block only them. It also says that changing DNS answers would break how the internet works and weaken security for everyone. For French users, this means losing a free tool that protects against online threats. The case also raises a big question: should people who run basic internet services be forced to block content they did not host?

What to watch

  • Whether Quad9 actually shuts down its service in France on November 24.
  • Whether beIN or the courts take further action against Quad9.
  • Whether other DNS providers face similar court orders in Europe.
  • Whether French users move to other security tools or DNS services.

Glossary

Quad9
A free, nonprofit internet service that protects users from harmful websites by answering their DNS lookups.
DNS resolver
A service that turns website names into internet addresses, like a phone book for the internet.
beIN
A Qatari TV company with offices in France that broadcasts sports and says its shows are being pirated.