US — Ars Technica
“Race realism” isn’t realistic—and it isn’t good science
Policy1 min read
An article argues that "race realism," the idea that racial groups differ in innate intelligence, is not real science. It says these views are returning in Western politics and social media.
What happened
At the World Economic Forum in Davos, US President Donald Trump said that people from Somalia have low IQs. His son, Donald Trump Jr, made a similar claim about Haitian people in 2024. The article says views like these are coming back into politics after being mostly hidden for about 70 years.
Why this idea keeps coming back
Some people call these ideas "race science" or "race realism." The article says they claim that Black or brown people are born less intelligent than white people. Some of these claims still appear in academic journals. A small network of writers also makes claims about intelligence, crime, and sexuality linked to race, and some of them work at universities.
Key facts
- About 70 years: how long these views were mostly hidden from public debate, according to the article.
- 2024: the year Donald Trump Jr made a similar claim about Haitian people.
- A handful of mainstream academic journals have published this kind of work.
Why it matters
The article says these ideas help fuel far-right propaganda and misinformation on social media. Because some of this work appears in respected journals, it can look like real science. The authors say it is methodologically flawed and does not use rigorous research, so it should not be trusted as science.
What to watch
- Whether more academic journals publish work like this.
- How politicians and social media use these claims in the coming years.
- The outcome of the plagiarism accusation made by Nathan Cofnas against Jason Arday.
Glossary
- race realism
- A name for the idea that racial groups differ in innate intelligence or behavior. The article says it is not real science.
- World Economic Forum
- A yearly international meeting in Davos, Switzerland, where world leaders and business people discuss global issues.
- methodologically flawed
- Means the way a study was done has serious errors, so its results cannot be trusted.
- far-right
- A political view that is very nationalist and often opposes immigration and equal rights for minority groups.
- plagiarism
- Copying someone else's work or ideas and presenting them as your own.