Archive — US — techcrunch
Not so fast: German court says Apple can’t call Watch carbon neutral
A German court ruled that Apple cannot claim its Watch Series 9 and Series 10 as carbon neutral due to carbon emissions from manufacturing. Although Apple offsets emissions through carbon credits, the court found the short lease terms of the eucalyptus tree projects inadequate for long-term sustainability, violating competition law expectations regarding carbon neutrality.
Key points
- Apple initially marketed its Watch Series 9 as carbon neutral, emphasizing no net emissions throughout its lifecycle.
- A lawsuit from the German environmental group Deutsche Umwelthilfe challenged this claim, focusing on the carbon offset approach.
- The court found that each watch generates over 8 kilograms of carbon emissions, which Apple offsets with carbon credits from tree planting.
- The trees are on leased land with leases expiring in 2029, ending before the expected long-term carbon offset needed by 2050, as indicated by the Paris Agreement.
- The judges ruled that customers might expect enduring carbon compensation and thus deemed Apple's claims misleading under German competition law.
Why it matters
- The ruling highlights increasing scrutiny on corporate carbon neutral claims as consumers grow more environmentally conscious.
- Reflects the trend of 2025 where accuracy in sustainability claims becomes pivotal due to stricter regulations and expectations from consumers.
- Similar cases are rising globally, emphasizing the importance of transparency in corporate carbon offset strategies.
This ruling underscores the challenging landscape for companies claiming carbon neutrality, as stringent legal interpretations require sustainable practices that extend beyond mere offsets.