UK — The Register
Signal slams door on prying AI agents to protect privacy
Security2 min read
Signal, the encrypted messaging app, now blocks AI agents such as Google Gemini and Apple Siri from reading its messages unless a user says yes. The company says the big phone makers do not give app developers easy ways to stop this kind of access.
What happened
Signal updated its iOS and Android apps. By default, the apps now stop Siri on iPhones and Gemini or other AI agents on Android from taking screenshots of messages. AI agents read the text in screenshots, so this blocks them from seeing private chats. Users can turn the block off in Signal's settings, but Signal warns that doing so can expose their messages and their contacts' messages to AI agents.
Why Signal is doing this
AI agents are programs that can look at what is on your screen and act for you. Signal's CEO, Meredith Whittaker, says Google and Apple are building these agents deep into their phone systems. To answer questions, the agents scan what is on the screen, so private messages can be copied and sent to company servers, where they are no longer private. Signal used a similar screenshot block last year to defend against Microsoft Recall, a feature that records screen activity.
Key facts
- Signal blocks screenshots by default in its iOS and Android apps.
- Users can turn the block off in Signal's settings menu.
- Screenshot blocking is only a partial fix, because AI agents may reach app data through the device file system.
- Apple's macOS 27.3, now in public beta testing, adds more permission prompts for apps that want user data.
Why it matters
Signal says it cannot fully protect private chats from AI agents yet. Signal also says it cannot add the same block on Mac. Its CEO says app makers need better tools from Google, Apple, and Microsoft to limit AI access without hurting the user experience. The story shows a growing clash between private apps and AI features built into phones.
What to watch
- Whether Apple, Google, and Microsoft give developers easier ways to limit AI agent access.
- How macOS 27.3 permission prompts work for users when the final version ships.
- Whether Signal can block AI access on macOS in the future.
Glossary
- Signal
- A messaging app that uses encryption to keep chats private.
- AI agent
- A computer program that can read what is on your screen and carry out tasks for you.
- Siri
- Apple's voice assistant that runs on iPhones and Macs.
- Gemini
- Google's AI assistant that is built into Android phones and other Google services.
- Microsoft Recall
- A Windows feature that saves snapshots of what is on the screen so users can search them later.