US — Ars Technica
San Diego dumps both Flock cameras and smart streetlights
Security1 min read
San Diego's city council voted to end contracts with two surveillance vendors, Flock and Ubicquia, which means the city will stop using Flock's cameras and Ubicquia's smart streetlights. Flock is a startup valued at an estimated $8.3 billion.
What happened
On Monday evening, San Diego's city council voted to end its contracts with Flock and Ubicquia. Flock makes camera systems that watch streets. Ubicquia makes smart streetlights. Mayor Todd Gloria said he respected the vote and would not veto it, so the cameras across the city will stop running.
Key facts
- Flock is estimated to be worth $8.3 billion.
- San Diego is one of the largest cities to end its work with Flock.
- The council vote covered two companies: Flock and Ubicquia.
- Councilmember Stephen Whitburn changed his position last month, which opened the way for a majority to vote to stop the surveillance.
Why the fight started
Groups like the TRUST SD Coalition have criticized city surveillance for years. The coalition says the public should have a say in how police and cities use watching tools. In October, Whitburn said he wanted residents to feel safe, and he argued that if the cameras made many people feel unsafe, they were no longer useful for public safety.
Why it matters
This decision shows that local voters and groups can push back on surveillance tools. Flock says the choice hurts public safety. The company argues that its cameras help solve violent crimes, catch retail theft crews, and find missing children. Critics see it as a win for privacy. The two sides disagree about how much these tools really help.
What to watch
- How San Diego police will solve cases without Flock cameras.
- Whether other big cities follow San Diego and end their Flock contracts.
- How Flock responds, and whether it changes its products or its pitch to cities.
Glossary
- Flock
- A startup that makes camera systems used to watch streets and help police. It is valued at an estimated $8.3 billion.
- Ubicquia
- A company that makes smart streetlights, which are streetlights with sensors or tech built in.
- TRUST SD Coalition
- A group of people in San Diego that criticizes city surveillance and wants the public to have a say in it.