KR — ZDNet Korea
DS Techno Files Invalidation Trial Against TCK's Semiconductor Etch Ring Patent Amendment
Chips2 min read
DS Techno has asked Korea's patent office to cancel TCK's patent correction for a silicon carbide (SiC) focus ring, which is used in chip etching. This is the latest step in a patent fight between the two companies that has lasted seven years.
DS Techno challenges TCK's patent fix
TCK, a maker of chip materials and parts, successfully corrected the wording of one of its SiC focus ring patents. DS Techno then filed a request on December 17 with the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) to declare that correction invalid. The patent is registered as No. 2117888 (the '888 patent). A focus ring is a part that wears out over time and is used in the etching step of chip making.
Key facts at a glance
- The IPTAB accepted TCK's correction request in October.
- In November 2023, the IPTAB ruled the '888 patent invalid. The Patent Court reversed that in October 2024.
- In July 2025, the IPTAB ruled the '888 patent valid after remand. DS Techno appealed in August 2025.
- TCK sued DS Techno for patent infringement in 2019.
- TCK's first three quarters of 2025: revenue of 300.4 billion won and operating profit of 85.6 billion won, a 28% operating margin.
A long fight over many patents
TCK sued DS Techno in 2019 for infringing its patents. In response, DS Techno challenged four TCK patents at the IPTAB. One patent (No. 1866869) was ruled invalid in January 2022. Another (No. 1914289) was partly valid and partly invalid, and DS Techno won a ruling that it did not infringe it. A third (No. 2208252) was ruled valid, and DS Techno dropped its appeal. Separately, TCK sued YMC and YCOM in 2020. A court found in 2024 that they infringed two TCK patents, and the companies settled in 2025.
Why this matters
A patent correction usually makes the patent's protection narrower. That makes it harder to prove that a rival infringes it. DS Techno likely thinks the corrected claims could still be judged as infringed, so it is fighting the change. The result will affect who can sell SiC focus rings in Korea and how strong TCK's patents are in court.
What to watch
- The IPTAB's decision on DS Techno's new invalidity request.
- The Patent Court's full hearing on the appeal over the '888 patent's validity.
- The Seoul Central District Court's ruling in the infringement lawsuit, which may differ from the IPTAB's view.
Glossary
- TCK
- A Korean company that makes silicon carbide parts used in chip manufacturing.
- DS Techno
- A Korean chip parts company that is in a patent dispute with TCK.
- SiC focus ring
- A consumable part made of silicon carbide that holds wafers in place during chip etching.
- IPTAB
- The Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board, which decides patent disputes before court.